Best finds from Cheryl's Cookies for the holidays 2023
Explore More
‘Tis the season for assembling your holiday decorations and gathering those who you hold dear. The best part about bringing people together? The delicious food around the table, of course.
This year, Cheryl’s Cookies is one of our favorite destinations for delectable desserts — a brand we simply have to place on your radar.
From boxes to towers and tins, rest assured the brand has you covered in the gifting department. Whether you’re hosting this year’s holiday bash or looking to bring a lovely (and sweet) gift to the host or hostess who you’ll be visiting, the brand has some of our favorite options.
“Founded in 1981, Cheryl’s Cookies has quickly grown a loyal customer following for its quality fresh-baked desserts using only the finest ingredients, including individually wrapped cookies, brownies and cakes,” the brand told The Post. “Headquartered in Westerville, Ohio, Cheryl’s Cookies is well-known for its cut-out cookies with buttercream frosting and its selection of specially designed, hand-crafted baked goods for everyday and special occasion gifting.”
Below, the New York Post listed our tried-and-true recommendations to ensure this holiday season is stress-free and as delicious as could be.
Not to mention, any of these options make wonderful last-minute gifts. But, don’t order too late. You’ll also receive 15% off sitewide using our exclusive code POST15 at checkout — only for New York Post readers.
The Holiday Tree Farm Frosted Cookie Crate — Medium is an adorable bundle filled with Christmas tree, snowflake and Santa buckled-cookies that are sure to be a delight to any dessert table this year. All of these yummy goodies come individually wrapped inside this festive, holly-jolly crate that doubles as decor when all the treats have been eaten.
We love a good charcuterie board around here, and the Holiday Charcuterie Board is a Cheryl’s Cookies must-have. Upon purchase, you’ll receive 15 snack-size butter shortbread tree cookies, two buttercream-frosted holiday cutout cookies, two snack-size buttercream-frosted red sprinkle cutout cookies, two snack-size chocolate chip cookies, two snack-size buttercream-frosted chocolate chocolate chip cookies and two chocolate tree holiday bark.
To complete your board, you’ll also receive one limited-edition buttercream-frosted “Be Merry” cutout cookie, one buttercream-frosted cranberry orange cookie, one buttercream-frosted s’more cookie, a bag of convection-covered holiday pretzels and a bag of wild cherry gummy bears.
Packed nicely and neatly in a festive package, the Traditional Happy Holidays Gift Tin — Holiday Cutouts is one to add to your online shopping cart. For less than $50, you’ll receive 15 buttercream-frosted holiday cutout cookies and a limited-edition buttercream-frosted “Be Merry” cutout cookie to garnish the bundle.
True and classic is the aesthetic of the Traditional Cutout Cookie Gift Box, an option at Cheryl’s Cookies that’s fitting for any budget. With 12 buttercream-frosted holiday cutout cookies and a limited-edition buttercream-frosted “Be Merry” cutout cookie, this assortment of sweet treats is one the entire family will enjoy.
Talk about merry packaging! The Happy Holidays Treats Gift Pail is less than $50 and is here to satisfy your sweet tooth. Inside, you’ll find four buttercream-frosted holiday cutout cookies, three chocolate pretzel clusters, two snack-size chocolate chip cookies, two snack-size oatmeal raisin cookies, two snack-size chocolate obsession cookies, two snack-size sugar cookies and two snack-size buttercream-frosted double chocolate chip cookies.
Making this tin a bit more unique than other offerings, it also includes a buttercream-frosted gingerbread cookie, a buttercream-frosted chocolate mint cookie and a large confection-covered pretzel.
The Premier Holiday Cookies gives “small but mighty” a whole new meaning. Its fairly priced at less than $40 and includes all of the classics to keep things festive, merry and bright this holiday season. Not to mention, its intricately decorated options will make any group of children smile with glee (adults, too!)
We can’t skip the Thanksgiving offerings this year. Now on sale, this perfectly accented basket will make a lovely centerpiece for your dining table.
Inside, you’ll find two limited-edition buttercream frosted turkey cutout cookies, two buttercream-frosted pumpkin cutout cookies, two peanut butter-frosted buckeye cookies (simply the best!), two caramel apple cookies, two buttercream-frosted maple sugar cookies and two rocky road pecan cookies – one of the most unique assortments yet.
The Thanksgiving Cookie Box is a treat to end the month of November on a high note. Whether for your Friendsgiving celebration or Thanksgiving Day, choose from your dozen-count or two-dozen count box for cinnamon pumpkin, snickerdoodle, butter pecan and more delicious, fall-inspired dessert options.
A gift tower always makes an incredible presentation, which is why $50 is the price to pay for the Traditional Happy Holidays Gift Tower. Topped with a satin bow, the stack-upon stack includes 15 snack-size butter shortbread tree cookies, four buttercream-frosted holiday cutout cookies, four snack-size buttercream-frosted red sprinkle cutout cookies and three chocolate pretzel clusters — for a salty kick.
Additionally, the tower is complete with two of the following: buttercream-frosted double chocolate chip cookies, traditional chocolate chip cookies, oatmeal raisin cookies, chocolate obsession cookies, sugar cookies and buttercream-frosted gingerbread cookies. Oh, how delightful.
Advent calendars always make us smile, and Cheryl’s Cookies has its 25 Treats of Christmas Advent Gift Box to make counting down to Christmas Day even sweeter! A cookie or sweet treat a day is just what you need to indulge in all the wintertime bliss this year.
The Entertainment Gift Basket — Large is the premier assortment to gift this year, just shy of $100. Not only does this bow-topped basket filled with all the goodies imaginable, but this bundle of deliciousness includes two vanilla pound cake slice, one lemon cake slice, one fudge brownie, one red velvet brookie and one buttercream-frosted hot cocoa brownie — in addition to a wealth of cookies.
Cheryl’s Cookies has much more to vouch for than simply cookies (though obviously, that’s the brand’s bread and butter — quite literally). The Cheryl’s Deluxe Brownie Gift Tin includes one blondie walnut bar, one toffee almond crunch bar, one oatmeal scotchie bar, one caramel fudge brownie and one pecan pie bar for a yummy variety.
Not only that, but you’ll also receive a red velvet brookie, a peanut butter-frosted buckeye brownie, a fudge brownie, a buttercream-frosted hot cocoa brownie and a chocolate mint layer bar for even more irresistible delicacies.
Check out the New York Post Shopping section for more content.
ncG1vNJzZmimqaW8tMCNnKamZ2Jlf3R7kGpmamtfqLWwvM%2BipaBnkprAtXnFoqWdq12bv7C5jJyfnqqpocBur86ooqKdo2KzsL6MrZ%2BeZZikuaqwwLKqZmpgZ4Bw